When there is no soul-searching, is the soul still there?
from The Sacredness of Questioning Everything by David Dark

We'll build new traditions in place of the old
'Cause life without revision will silence our souls
from "Snow" by Sleeping at Last

Monday, September 19, 2011

Genesis = the origin, the formation

The Sunday school class Jason and I are becoming a part of at Parkway is studying the book of Genesis; from the look of it we will be studying it for a while, and I'm finding myself almost surprisingly fascinated. What is the origin of the world? Of life? Love? Beauty? Art? Humanity? I reflected earlier this summer that I simply have to believe in God, that for me there can be no other option. I cannot believe that something as complex and driven by emotion and a sense of the possibility of perfect good and beauty can exist without a source of perfection, good, emotion. 


As expanses-of-the-sky wide open as I am about the specifics of the book of Genesis, its history, and how it is to be understood and interpreted, I do not doubt that the origin is God. In six days, six seconds, or the entire Darwinian process of centuries and centuries, everything came to be, I truly believe, at the word of God. At His breath. At His command.


A study I found online has directed me to several places in Scripture aside from Genesis that refer to the formation of the world and our Creator's foreknowledge and authority in the process. I don't know why. I want to be so logical, have such proof and rationale... yet all I have to say is this feels right. Something about the story of God as our Creator (and as our Redeemer I must equally emphasize) just fills all the gaps for me somehow... I will think about how I might express that more articulately and informatively.


All I really know to say is that I want the one in whom "all things hold together." How can I not yearn for that? I have to have hope in one who made this world, one who has the power to continue to form it, to transform it into what it should have been...
If you address as Father the One who impartially judges according to each one's work, conduct yourselves in fear during the time of your stay on earth; knowing that you were not redeemed with perishable things like silver or gold from your futile way of life inherited from your forefathers, but with precious blood, as of a lamb unblemished and spotless, the blood of Christ. For He was foreknown before the foundation of the world, but has appeared in these last times for the sake of you who through Him are believers in God, who raised Him from the dead and gave Him glory, so that your faith and hope are in God. 1 Peter 1:17-21
By faith we understand that the worlds were prepared by the word of God, so that what is seen was not made out of things which are visible. Hebrews 11:3 
He [Christ] is before all things and in Him all things hold together. Colossians 1:17
[...] that which is known about God is evident within them; for God made it evident to them. For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made, so that the are without excuse. Romans 1:19-20 

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Better not to want the world too much

Who could envy Cain his hunger? Better to be circumspect and silent. Better not to want the world too much. Left alone with the body of his brother, Cain began to assemble the words about what Abel had done and what he had been forced to do in return. It was a long story. It took his entire lifeto tell it. And even then it wasn’t finished.How great language had to become to encompass its deft evasions and sly contradictions, its preenings and self-satisfied gloatings.Each generation makes a contribution, hoping to have got it right at last. The sun rises and sets. The leaves flutter like a million frightened hands. Confidently, we step forward and tack a few meager phrases onto the end.

Each generation makes a contribution, hoping to have got it right at last.


Hoping to have got it right at last.


I love the book of Ecclesiastes, and  I am constantly reminded that Solomon has it right when he says there is nothing new under the sun. Generation after generation, we're following the same patterns with different specifics. Struggling and striving as those before us, trying to add meaning that hasn't been added before... just to "tack a few meager phrases onto the end."


And as I speed re-read Ecclesiastes this morning, noting all the portions I have circled and identified with in the past in the exact same way I identify with them this morning, I am not apathetic or pessimistic or down-trodden or hopeless as it might sound.


How is it possible that I don't really find the refrain of Ecclesiastes "Vanity of vanities! All is vanity!" hopeless? Somehow, this morning, it is not hopeless, but hope in something that is not vain, a reminder of the proper perspective of humanity, which is to remember that our lives are brief, a repetition of lives before us and without control over the lives that come after, lives that are filled with vanities, futilities, inconsistencies, and injustices. We struggle to make meaning of every aspect of our corporal lives, and, in trying to get it right, we all follow different paths, some wisdom, some riches, some work, some religion, and  in the end it is all the same. As Hamlet reflected over the skull of Yorrick, Solomon said it centuries before: "One fate befalls them both."


There is nothing new under the sun. Why then, do I search for the point as if it is something that can be discovered that hasn't been discovered before?


I think if I could just study enough... if I could just be wise enough... but the problem with the whole thing is that my perspective is rooted in the idea that I, a human, can grasp it and can get it right, and that perspective is foolishness. There is only one point: God. It's a point I can't ever understand, but that's the point. And this morning, I am rejoicing in that.


But beyond this, my son, be warned: the writing of many books is endless, and the excessive devotion to books is wearing to the body. The conclusion, when all has been heard, is: fear God and keep His commandments, because this applies to every person. For God will bring every act to judgement, everything which is hidden, whether it is good or evil. Ecclesiastes 12:12-14
And I  saw every work of God, I concluded that man cannot discover the work which has been done under the sun. Even though man should seek laboriously, he will not discover; and though the wise man should say, "I know," he cannot discover. Ecclesiastes 8:17
He has made everything appropriate in its time. He has also set eternity in their hearts, yet so that man will not find out the work which God has done from the beginning even to the end. Ecclesiastes 3:11 


The Point and Grasping for It

I had no intention of opening this with any sort of metaphor, but as I typed the title and thought about the point, I was reminded of my pencil sharpener at school. It's one of the old-fashioned wall mounted kind, but I've loved it because it has worked better, longer, and more quietly than any of the multiple electrical sharpeners I've purchased since being a teacher. Lately, though, something in it has gotten jammed or dull, and it now frequently sharpens pencils only on one side, leaving wood covering the graphite completely on one side of the point. Because of this, kids stand in lines half-a-dozen children long sharpening their pencils until they break and trying again and again and again, only to produce pencils that have sharp points but are unusable because of the side still enveloped in wood.


The whole process is frustrating, and at some point, I always have to intervene and force the pencil to sharpen or trade the students' unusable pencils for ones I have sharpened before class in an attempt to eliminate the lost time of endless pencil sharpening.


Sometimes, on mornings like this one, I feel like I'm one of the kids standing at the pencil sharpener, sharpening and sharpening and sharpening. Pencil dust is flying everywhere, and I'm turning the handle as carefully as I can, trying not to break the graphite as I sharpen, but each time I pull out my pencil, praying that it has a usable point, it is either one-sided or broken. Again and again. One sided or broken. Unusable. And I'm starting to get impatient and there are other kids waiting on me to finish, relying on my success for their chance at the pencil sharpener, but still, despite my urgency and desire for success, I keep wearing down my pencil, smaller and smaller and one sided or broken.




Today, I could be in Sunday school. I was running late this morning, but I could have made it. But I didn't leave. I decided to stay here and do this instead because I simply don't know what the point would be in going. What's the point? What's the purpose?


I want a community, true. I want to learn more about God and this Christian life that I'm trying to live, true. Both of those would be stated purposes for attending Sunday school, for attending church, and I want them. But is that what I'm getting by making sure I attend like I'm supposed to? Is that what I'm getting by reading my Bible and Sunday school lessons? Is that what I'm getting by reading more books and spending time in my blog? Am I really getting closer to anything? Is there really a point? Or is the pencil just emerging, lesson after lesson, book after book, as either one sided or broken?

Saturday, July 23, 2011

A poem my last post makes me think of for some reason...

Long Story by Stephen Dobyns

There must have been a moment after the expulsion
from the Garden where the animals were considering
what to do next and just who was in charge.
The bear flexed his muscles, the tiger flashed
his claws, and even the porcupine thought himself
fit to rule and showed off the knife points
of his quills. No one noticed the hairless creatures,
with neither sharp teeth, nor talons, they were too puny.
It was then Cain turned and slew his own brother
and Abel’s white body lay sprawled in the black dirt
as if it had already lain cast down forever.
What followed was an instant of prophetic thought
as the trees resettled themselves, the grass
dug itself deeper into the ground and all
grew impressed by the hugeness of Cain’s desire.
He must really want to be boss, said the cat.
This was the moment when the animals surrendered
the power of speech as they crept home to the bosoms
of their families, the prickly ones, the smelly ones,
the ones they hoped would never do them harm.
Who could envy Cain his hunger? Better to be circumspect
and silent. Better not to want the world too much.
Left alone with the body of his brother, Cain began
to assemble the words about what Abel had done
and what he had been forced to do in return.
It was a long story. It took his entire life
to tell it. And even then it wasn’t finished.
How great language had to become to encompass
its deft evasions and sly contradictions,
its preenings and self-satisfied gloatings.
Each generation makes a contribution, hoping
to have got it right at last. The sun rises
and sets. The leaves flutter like a million
frightened hands. Confidently, we step forward
and tack a few meager phrases onto the end

There's a story I need to tell...

While reading Same Kind of Different as Me (which I highly recommend), I came across this passage by Ron Hall with Lynn Vincent-- a passage that sums up a lot of thoughts that have been in my heart and mind in the past year or two:
I guess we were pretty good at the whole Christian thing-- or maybe we were bad at it-- because we managed to alienate many of our old college friends. With our new spiritual eyes, we could see they didn’t have fish stickers either, and we set about saving them from eternal damnation with all the subtlety of rookie linebackers. Looking back now, I mourn the mutual wounds inflicted in verbal battles with the "unsaved." In fact, I have chosen to delete that particular term from my vocabulary as I have learned that even with my $500 European-designer bifocals, I cannot see into a person’s heart to know his spiritual condition. All I can do is tell the jagged tale of my own spiritual journey and declare that my life has been the better for having followed Christ.

Hall’s words sear into me when he talks about verbal battles and saving others from eternal damnation. Faces of dear friends whom I tried to “save” in high school-- like that was my job and not God’s-- come to my mind, and I remember bitter cynics I met in classes in college who probably had every right to be cold and harsh toward evangelical Christians.   It doesn’t take many episodes of The 700 Club, news broadcasts about Christians burning holy books or storming soldiers’ funerals with signs that say “God hates you,” saccharine speeches of Joel Osteen, failed predictions of the end of time, or  fire and brimstone stories that smack of the same mixture of lie and ultimatum your parents gave you in the Santa Claus presents vs. coal scenario to make even a believing Christian like me doubt the whole crazy thing. Of course people are cynics. It doesn’t take much wit or way with words to poke plenty of holes in Christianity. I believe, and I like to think I can do it with the best of ‘em.
“Is there anyone who ever remembers changing their mind from the paint on a sign? Is there anyone who really recalls ever breaking rank at all for something someone yelled real loud one time?” So go the opening lyrics to John Mayer’s “Belief.” I think of these lines every time I drive I-40 East from Nashville to Newport and contemplate the gigantic billboard inquisition “If you died today, where would you spend eternity?” and as I drive through Knoxville, wondering if the city’s half a dozen billboards with rip-your-heart-out anti-abortion ads that say things like “Mommy, I forgive you. You didn’t know what you were doing. Love, the Unborn” have actually ever helped anyone escape hell at all-- either the literal, physical, eternal afterlife one or the literal, physical, emotional, here-and-now-on-earth hell that I can only imagine the experience of having an abortion must be.
I don’t know that I’ve deleted the word “unsaved” from my vocabulary, but I know I hate using it, and I hate using the word “saved” for that matter too. I don’t like to talk to about “when I got saved” like it was a one-time magical event or like I had even a speck to do with it in comparison to how much God had to do with it, and while the word is used to describe followers of Christ in Scripture, I think it has been tainted in our culture with too many unintended meanings to keep using it as a main part of my vocabulary at least. I do know, though, like Ron Hall, that there is certainly no way for me to tell if someone else is or isn’t saved-- whatever exactly that means-- and I’ve been quite through for a quite a long time with the practice of telling people that they need to get saved or how to do it. 
At the same time, however, it doesn’t sit well in me to stay silent about what I believe. I feel like a liar and a coward not being bold about my faith. As cynical as I am about almost every way I’ve ever seen evangelism happen, and as surely as I believe that not many people-- if any-- really change their minds from just the paint on a sign, I still feel that something is missing from my faith if I don’t talk about it, if don’t share it.
If I know of a sale at a clothing store that I know a friend loves as much as I do, I make sure she knows about it. If I read a good book, I lend it to a friend. If I know a good doctor or hairdresser, I recommend that person. I sang the praises of Indian Lake AT&T on Facebook and to everyone I saw for days just because the guy behind the counter let me in right at closing time and gave me a new SIM card so my phone would work again. I insist on sharing favorite movies and songs with others, and I tell everyone I know that they simply have to have Sweet CeCe’s if they haven’t before. Seriously.
So what must my faith, my Jesus, my God mean to me if I never really even bring them up? How important can they really be in my life if they’re less worth mentioning than the brand of straightening iron I use or what Taylor Swift song I’m really digging right now?
Of course, it’s not as simple as that. It’s not so much that I don’t think it’s important as it is that I don’t want to push my beliefs on anyone. Sharing interests and day-to-day information doesn’t have so much potential bite to it. After all, it’s not like I tell my friends that they’re going to go to hell or-- doctrines of eternity aside-- that their life won’t be as full or satisfying without a hot pink CHI or sprinkling cereal on top of frozen yogurt. Not even the president of the Taylor-Swift-Can’t-Sing Club is going to be that offended-- at least not for long-- just because I tagged her in a note with the lyrics to Taylor’s latest bubble gum sweet toe-tapping tune. It’s just not that big a deal.
But tag an “unbelieving” friend in a note about their need for Jesus, give them a Bible instead of your favorite recent bestseller for their birthday, or recommend the living water that can satisfy even long after the Sweet CeCe’s dish is empty, and you’re treading on much more sensitive, divisive turf. Religion, faith, belief-- these are so much more personal than a sale at the Gap Outlet. And I wouldn’t want to hurt anyone’s feelings, send the wrong message, be judgmental, push them farther away, ruin a relationship forever...
But, religion, faith, belief-- they’re so much more important to me than a sale at the Gap Outlet. Why am I willing to let relationships with people I care about stay at such a superficial level that I’m afraid to talk about anything more personal than musical preferences and places to eat? Even more important, less vapid topics that I can and do discuss with friends-- things like politics, thoughts and philosophies, education-- those things aren’t as important to me either. I act like they are. My time, attention, and conversations certainly reflect that they are. But I know that they’re just pieces, just parts, just shadowy reflections of what I really want to explore and know and be a part of-- God.
So here’s what I have to work on-- telling that jagged tale of my  own spiritual journey and learning how to explain, somehow, that my life is better with Jesus. And not better in a “I pray to God and He sees fit to give all good gifts to me to bless my life” way. And not better in a more holy or more “good” way. And not any better than anyone else either.
Just better. 
Better because it all just makes more sense, feels more complete, seems to explain what I feel echoed, whispered, promised in everything-- literature as old and older than the Bible, ballet, a sky full of stars, the ideals of love and compassion and sacrifice that seem to weave through every story that moves me, music, art, academia. Everything in history, all of humanity, is groaning for something-- striving for better, reaching for perfection, longing for and looking for wholeness. 
A student gave me a page of quotations she liked because she thought I would enjoy them, and I recently painted one of them onto a canvas to hang in my classroom. It's attributed to Ernst Haas, who a quick Google search reveals is a photographer and one whose work I want to explore and share with my students. He said, “A picture is the expression of an impression. If beauty were not in us, how would we ever recognize it?” That’s how I feel about God. Somehow, everything in art and history seems to proclaim that man is searching for beauty, finding glimmers of it, striving to preserve it, express it, create more of it, celebrate what of it he can find in himself and those around him. Art wouldn’t change if it had been perfected yet. Technology and society wouldn’t continue to advance if there were no room left for progress. All of human history, all of my history as a human, seems to be just one long story of progressing, advancing, carrying on toward beauty and perfection. How could we long for it if it didn’t exist somewhere? Why can we not attain it if it is not beyond humanity itself, if it is not something more, something purer, vaster, more full and complete than we can understand?
It is not possible for me not to believe in God. Surely He must exist. It seems to me it stands to reason that love, hope, joy, and beauty must derive from somewhere beyond the functions of chemicals in the human brain. Science tells us that matter can be neither created nor destroyed, but surely it must have a source somewhere; if it cannot be created, how does it exist at all? Surely there must be something to bestow the initial finite amount of “stuff” in the universe.
And surely personalities and spirits, emotions and thoughts have origin not in cold impersonal chemicals but in a spirit, in an entity with personality, emotions, and love. God.
Now I realize the next logical step is the question of who/what created God, and that is a “chicken or egg” kind of conundrum, but somehow I am not at odds with the idea of an uncreated deity as much as I am with the idea of an uncreated human. It is problematic for me to try to assume that nothing created humanity and that it simply exists. It is far more logical and fathomable to me that something exists beyond me-- something so complex that it is beyond my realm, beyond my understanding, somehow able to exist by its own accord and for its own sake. It is impossible, however, for me to believe that something as complex but ultimately powerless as humans could simply be, simply happen, simply exist without any idea of how we came to be so.
John Mayer goes on to sing that belief is “a beautiful armor that makes for the heaviest sword- like punching underwater, you never can hit who you’re trying for.” I’ve become fearful of the sword of belief, petrified of wielding it clumsily, misaiming, and shattering, scarring people I care about.
But “how will they call on Him in whom they have not believed? How will they believe in Him whom they have not heard?” (Romans 10:14) How can anyone I know know of what faith, belief, God mean to me and have done in me, if I am always silent? If I don’t consider Jesus a name to be said more than those of human musicians, authors, and politicians? 
How do I even begin to tell my jagged story? What do I say? How do I convince anyone that this is not what John Mayer writes off as a “chemical weapon for the war that’s raging on inside.” Faith for me is not “an exhibition,” an attempt that I feel compelled to make at being good or doing the right thing. It is something that is real, liberating, all-encompassing.
I’ve got to get better at telling that story, and I’ve got to start telling it. Genuinely. Not in a way that’s like verbally condemning someone who’s lactose intolerant for not trying Sweet CeCe’s but in a way that’s like recommending a doctor to someone who’s actually looking for one, like lending a book to someone who might truly enjoy reading it.
It’s the story that defines my life, who I am, everything that matters. It’s a story worth telling to everyone who cares at all to hear...

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Motivation

Motivation.


What motivates you? What moves you? What determines how you live your life?


When I talk to Jason about ideas and theology and the questions and theories swirling around me and in me, there is usually a point in the conversation where he can't help but ask, "What difference does it make? Is your life any different if you believe one way or the other?"


As I quibble over details, I have to ask his question "What difference does it make?"


Usually, the answer should theoretically be "It makes all the difference," but then I look at my life and the lives of others around me, and I have to say that people who believe on either side of a question usually live in about the same way.


Here's a perfect example of this quibbling and questioning and the perplexing case of what life looks like on either side of the theories: What happens when we die? As a Protestant Christian, I'm supposed to have a clear, undeniable answer to that. You know, the one that goes something like if we've accepted Jesus we spend eternity in Heaven with Him and if we have not accepted Jesus, have denied Him, or have never even heard of Him, we spend eternity in Hell. Maybe that clear, undeniable answer is right. There are certainly plenty of good arguments that it is, Scripture that does in fact seem to point in that direction, and years of tradition to support it. However, in my mind at least and in the minds of many others, there is plenty to call that clear, undeniable answer into question. Maybe nothing happens, and this is just all there is. Maybe there is a Heaven and Hell kind of situation but not the clouds and halos and fire and brimstone cartoon variations our culture imagines. Maybe there's an eternity that Christians will miss out on because we've gotten it all wrong all these centuries just like the Pharisees and other "brood of viper" types always did even when they were looking Jesus in the face. Maybe Jesus IS the Way but in a different way than the exclusive evangelical Christian way we've interpreted Him to be. Really, who honestly knows? All I can do is choose one to believe the best that I can, based on what I discern from Scripture, academics, prayer, or whatever method of logic, learning, or gut-following I decide to employ.


And there's Jason's question, "What difference does it make?" Well, it makes all the difference. If Jesus is the Only Way, in the exclusive way that we believe He is and everyone who doesn't know Him is destined to an eternity without Him, how should we live? We should be living no less than extremely, radically, only to make His name and way of salvation known. That's it. There shouldn't be any other ambition, any other goals, any other way to spend a moment. Jesus said to leave behind family, to "let the dead bury their own dead," to take up crosses. He used such strong language of leaving all else behind to follow Him. If He is the Way, that's all life should be, right? I mean, what's the point of anything else? Everything else is just a distraction, an earthly idolatry, and a waste of precious time that could be used to make sure that we and everyone else around us goes to Heaven in the end.


If the truth is something a little less extreme and exclusive than that, though, life is a little different. There's less urgency, less need. At least when it comes to the question of eternity, that is. In the here and now, perhaps there is more urgency, more need to make life beautiful and satisfying for ourselves and for others in the world. If nothing happens when we die or nothing that we can be certain of or fully control, then we just make our best possible choice  and try to have a good life and, if we're nice and generous, make the lives of others nice too.


Now, before any of my readers or I write-off the second option for its lack of the truth of Christ, think about it. What do most Christians claim to believe about the question of what happens when we die? Most claim the Heaven through relationship with Jesus only route. Now, how many Christians live like that's true? Seriously. If we believed it's true, really honestly, deeply believed that in our hearts, why would we have any job other than that of a missionary? Why would we bother praying for new jobs or for our finances when we should be praying for salvation for humanity and selling everything we do have to give our money to the poor? Why would we marry or produce children when there are so many already alive and yet unsaved people to attend to? How selfish to create more people-- with the possibility that they may go to Hell no less!-- when there are plenty of other people who need our time and energy to know Jesus.


Back to the word motivation. Back to the question What motivates you? 


I think about Jehovah's Witnesses walking through our neighborhoods in 90+ weather wearing suits and knocking on doors to tell people about what they believe. I think about people going to war or strapping bombs to themselves in the name of religion. What motivates that? Why am I not motivated like that?


The question bothers me deeply. Why am I not motivated? Why am I not bursting to go to the ends of the earth to tell the Gospel of Jesus? Why do I not tell everyone I know about what Jesus means to me? Why am I not knocking on my neighbors' doors to see how I can help them and if I can share my testimony with them? Why am I not thoroughly convinced that that is the right course of action for my life?


I always go back to this idea in David Dark's The Sacredness of Questioning Everything:


My religion is my practice.  It's what I do. (pg. 35)  Will we allow a religious critique of our practice of religion?  Are we up for a redeeming word?  Show me a transcript of the words you've spoken, typed, or texted in the course of a day, an account of your doings, and a record of your transactions, and I'll show you your religion.  (pg. 38)
Even if I am a very religious Christian who goes to church several times a week, reads my Bible twice a day, and prays for everyone I know, there is still going to be a huge part of my life that involves going to work, fixing dinner, eating, cleaning the bathroom, shopping, watching TV. What then is my religion? The religious part of my day or the rest of it? Is the goal to eliminate everything else so that only the religion remains?

Jason has another recurring question, "Can you be a Christian and still like baseball?", meaning can there be any other enjoyment in your life or anything else to take your time if you're truly committed to Christ?

I'm stuck somewhere between the answer that everything is Spiritual and the answer that nothing that looks different from the lives of the Apostles is Spiritual.

What difference do the questions make? None if they're just questions, things to ponder, read about, write about... I want to believe that if I could answer some of my questions conclusively, I could figure out the best way to wrap my life around those answers, to live so that the records and transcripts of my days point to a religion that follows Jesus completely.

Right now, though, it's all just questions and books and day-to-day... thinking about teaching, checking emails from LOFT and shopping for new clothes, reading the Harry Potter series, thumbing through stacks and stacks of teaching materials and making plans, spending time with my husband and friends and family, decorating and cleaning my house again and again, keeping up with reality shows on TV, staying busy and struggling not to be busy,  going to church, wondering and theorizing about God and how He works, being a generally good person and trying to get better, struggling to refine my passions for writing and teaching into being something worthwhile in the world, and trying to find the balance of how to spend the hours of this life in the best way possible... all the while knowing that it isn't fair all I have when others do not, all the while knowing there's so much more to be done in this world...

What motivates me? What should motivate me? And what should it motivate me to do?


Academy Award Winners... I still have some movies to watch...

It greatly bothers me that these movie titles are in quotation marks because I teach my students that movie titles are underlined or italicized... Ah well, I'll let the Academy make its own style choices.

The ones that are bold and orange are the ones I've seen. My favorite of the ones I've watched so far? Casablanca without a doubt.